Rent vs Buy Calculator
Compare the cash you spend and the amount you finish with when you rent or buy on the same monthly budget.
Starting position
60 months is 5 years.
Home and mortgage
Include any transfer duty and conveyancing fees.
Allow for rates, insurance and maintenance.
Growth and sale
Enter a share of the sale price.
Enter the annual return.
Results
Final position difference
−$3,346
Buying minus rentingFinal position renting
$205,885
Renter savings balanceFinal position buying
$202,539
Buyer savings plus net sale equityRenting cash outgoings
$162,366
Rent paid over the periodBuying cash outgoings
$355,920
Deposit, purchase and sale costs plus repayments and running costsMonthly mortgage repayment
$2,877.84
Remaining mortgage
$446,661
Net sale equity
$202,539
After selling costs and mortgage payoutBuyer savings balance
$0
Final position: $205,885 renting and $202,539 buying. Buying minus renting: −$3,346.
Financial position by month
Final position: $205,885 renting and $202,539 buying. Buying minus renting: −$3,346.
Illustrative inputs. The monthly budget follows the higher housing outflow. Moving costs and separate taxes are outside the model.
Compare Renting and Buying on Equal Terms
The rent vs buy calculator gives both options the same starting cash and time period. The renter invests that cash. The buyer pays purchase costs first, then uses the remaining cash for the deposit up to the home price. Any cash left after buying goes into the buyer’s savings.
Each month, the calculator sets a shared budget equal to the higher of rent or the mortgage repayment plus ownership costs. Each option invests what it has left at the end of the month. A path that uses the full budget contributes $0. If rising rent overtakes ownership costs, the buyer starts making the surplus contributions.
Part of each mortgage repayment reduces the loan balance and builds equity. The interest portion is a cost. The mortgage uses the same constant-rate, principal-and-interest approach as Moneysmart’s mortgage calculator.
Include Purchase, Holding and Exit Costs
Enter the transfer duty, conveyancing fees and other upfront costs for the purchase you’re comparing. Annual ownership costs can include council rates, insurance, strata fees and maintenance. The calculator spreads those costs evenly over the year and keeps them fixed in dollars.
Rent rises or falls on each anniversary. The home value and savings compound monthly at rates equivalent to their separate annual assumptions. Each month, the savings balance earns its entered after-tax return before any new contribution goes in.
The calculator applies the selling cost percentage to the final property value, then subtracts the remaining loan. The buyer’s net sale equity can be negative if the sale proceeds fall short of the loan payout. Buying cash outgoings include the deposit and selling costs. The final loan payout comes from sale proceeds in the equity calculation.
The model excludes moving costs and any tax beyond the transfer duty you enter and the after-tax savings return. An option-to-buy contract has its own calculation for option payments and rent credits.
Follow a Matched Housing Example
Suppose you start with $140,000 and compare five years of renting at $600 a week with buying a $600,000 home. The buyer pays $20,000 in purchase costs and puts $120,000 down, leaving $0 in savings. The renter starts with all $140,000 invested.
The buyer takes a $480,000 mortgage for 30 years at an illustrative 6% annual rate. Enter $6,000 a year in ownership costs, 2% annual rent growth and 2% annual home value growth. Selling costs are 2% of the final home value. Savings earn an assumed 3% a year after tax.
The monthly repayment is P × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)^(−n)). Here P is the loan amount, r is the annual mortgage rate divided by 12 and n is the number of monthly payments. At 0% interest, the repayment is P ÷ n.
At 6%, the monthly rate is 0.5% and the repayment is $2,877.84. In month one, $2,400.00 is interest and $477.84 reduces the loan balance. The model retains full precision between months and rounds the figures for display.
Weekly rent converts to $2,600 a month ($600 × 52 ÷ 12). The buyer’s first-month outflow is $3,378 including $500 in ownership costs. That sets the shared budget. The renter invests $778 in month one and $564 in month 60 as rent rises. The buyer invests $0 each month.
| Five-year result | Renting | Buying |
|---|---|---|
| Opening savings after purchase costs and deposit | $140,000 | $0 |
| Total monthly savings contributions | $40,304 | $0 |
| Closing savings balance | $205,885 | $0 |
| Remaining mortgage | None | $446,661 |
| Net sale equity | None | $202,539 |
| Final position | $205,885 | $202,539 |
The modelled sale price is $662,448, with $13,249 in selling costs. After clearing the mortgage, $202,539 in sale equity plus $0 in savings leaves the buyer with $202,539. The renter has $205,885 in savings, so buying minus renting is −$3,346.
Read the Difference and Test the Assumptions
A positive final position difference means buying leaves more money at the end. A negative difference means renting leaves more. The starting mortgage repayment exceeds rent by $277.84 a month in this example. The final difference also reflects the deposit, expenses, investment growth and sale equity.
Change one assumption at a time to see how much it moves the difference. These are scenarios for the same starting figures, with each row changing only the item shown.
| Scenario | Buying minus renting |
|---|---|
| Starting example | −$3,346 |
| Home value stays flat | −$64,545 |
| Rent rises by 6% a year | +$10,751 |
| Stay for two years | −$23,193 |
The shorter stay leaves fewer months to repay the mortgage and less time for a rise in home value. The purchase and selling costs still apply. The calculator models your entered financial assumptions. The value you place on flexibility or owning your home is personal.
