Unfair Contract Terms in Broker Agreements

Australia’s unfair contract terms laws protect small brokerages that sign standard form agreements. If an aggregator can cut your commission split without notice, ask what justifies that power, what it could cost you and what rights you have in return. Apply the same test to the engagement terms you give clients.

What Unfair Contract Terms Are

A court applies three tests to an unfair contract term. It must create a significant imbalance in the parties’ rights and obligations, exceed what the advantaged party reasonably needs to protect its legitimate interests and cause detriment if used. The advantaged party must show why the term is reasonably necessary.

The court looks at the whole agreement and whether the clause is easy to find, legible, clearly presented and written in plain language. The tests are in section 24 of the Australian Consumer Law and section 12BG of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001.

An unfair term is void. The rest of the agreement still binds the parties if it can operate without that term. Under the 2023 reforms, a court can also impose penalties for proposing an unfair term in a covered contract or applying or relying on one. A court can impose separate penalties for separate terms.

The reforms apply to covered contracts made or renewed from commencement. If an older contract was only varied on or after commencement, the amended rules apply to the term that changed or was added. The updated test for whether the contract is standard form applies to the whole contract. Use the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission’s contract guidance for the exact commencement date.

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) enforces the Australian Consumer Law. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) enforces the corresponding provisions of the ASIC Act.

When a Small Business Contract is Covered

Check how the agreement was negotiated, whether a party met the small business test and what the contract supplies.

  1. Check whether it is standard form. The court considers who had bargaining power, whether one party prepared the terms in advance and how often it used similar terms. It also looks at whether you had a real chance to negotiate and whether the terms reflected your business or the transaction. Choosing among preset options or making small edits can still leave it a standard form contract. If a party alleges in court that the contract is standard form, the court presumes it is unless another party proves otherwise.
  2. Identify the entity that signed the agreement. At least one party must meet either the employee test or the turnover test. The employee test requires fewer than 100 staff when the party makes the contract in the course of business. The turnover test requires less than $10 million in the party’s previous income year. Check the signatory’s payroll or turnover records. Count regular and systematic casuals and count part-time staff as fractions of full-time equivalents. Calculate turnover under the applicable Act if it is close to the threshold.
  3. Identify what the agreement supplies. The Australian Consumer Law covers most ordinary supply contracts, including many franchise and supplier agreements. There is no upfront price cap under that regime. For financial products and services, the ASIC Act limits coverage of small business contracts to those with an upfront price of $5 million or less. Interest on credit is excluded from that calculation. See ASIC’s small business guidance.

ASIC lists broker agreements among the contracts small businesses commonly enter into for financial products and services. For an aggregator agreement that combines credit intermediation with software, training or administrative support, have a lawyer assess which regime applies to the agreement you signed.

Check Commission and Trail Book Terms

Read the commission schedule with the clauses that let the aggregator or franchisor change it, recover payments or terminate the agreement. For each clause, write down what triggers it, who decides, what it could cost and whether you get notice or an opportunity to respond.

  • Commission splits and fees. Can the provider cut your split or raise fees unilaterally? Check whether a change reaches loans you already settled and whether you can leave on the existing terms.
  • Clawback recovery. Compare the provider’s right to deduct money with the lender’s commission clawback schedule. Ask what supports any recovery beyond what the lender recovered or any deduction the provider can make before explaining the amount.
  • Trail book on exit. Check who owns the rights to trail, who keeps receiving it after termination and which sums may be deducted. If you are switching mortgage aggregators, get the treatment of existing trail in writing before you give notice.
  • Termination without cause. Check how much notice the provider owes you and what happens to pending settlements and accrued commission. In a franchise, compare the clause with the ACCC’s franchise agreement guidance.
  • One-way indemnities. An indemnity makes you cover specified losses. Check whether you would pay for losses the provider caused and whether the obligation goes beyond risks your brokerage controls.

For example, suppose a provider uses a variation clause to cut a brokerage’s trail share from 80% to 60%. On $5,000 in monthly gross trail before fees, the brokerage would receive $3,000 instead of $4,000. That is $1,000 less a month. The lost income shows the possible detriment. For the other parts of the test, check whether the brokerage can leave on its existing split and why the provider needs the power to change it.

Save the signed agreement, all schedules and every variation or renewal notice with the commission records. Keep the date each change took effect. If a deduction appears, record the loan reference, affected statement periods, amount and the clause the provider cites. Retain the relevant part of the lender’s statement as well if you have it.

Unfair Terms in Your Own Client Agreements

A standard form mortgage broker fee agreement with an individual arranging a loan primarily for personal, family or household use can also be tested. ASIC’s consumer contract guidance explains the financial services rules. Review your engagement letter and any fee schedule the client receives before agreeing.

Flag terms that let you raise fees after signing, charge a large cancellation fee regardless of the work done or require a client to cover loss you caused. Also check terms that let the brokerage end the engagement without giving the client a comparable right. Ask what risk each clause addresses, how the fee relates to the work and what the client loses if you use it.

The test generally excludes terms that define the main subject of the contract, set its disclosed upfront price or are required or expressly permitted by law. Review the separate rights to change a fee or charge a fee when a future event occurs. A contingent fee can sit outside the upfront price exclusion.

What to Do About a Suspect Term

  1. Raise the clause in writing. Quote it, identify the agreement version and explain the likely effect on your brokerage. Ask for the reason it is needed and propose a specific change, such as written notice before any new split applies.
  2. Seek legal advice on coverage, deadlines and practical remedies, especially if termination, withheld trail or a large deduction is imminent. Give the lawyer the agreement, change notices and statements.
  3. Use the aggregator’s or franchisor’s dispute process. Check the notice method, response time and escalation steps in the agreement. For a franchise dispute, the ACCC’s dispute guide explains how to seek help with mediation.
  4. Report a suspected breach of the Australian Consumer Law to the ACCC. For suspected misconduct involving financial products or services under the ASIC Act, report it to ASIC. Keep pursuing the remedy for your own dispute through the appropriate dispute process or with your lawyer.
Track My Trail

Trail analysis, simplified

Less time checking your trail, more time growing your book.

See how it works

7 days free · No credit card

Track My Trail Team

Read more

We develop software to simplify trail book management for mortgage brokers. Our tools provide fast and practical insights to help brokers get the most out of their trail books.

Track My Trail
See how it works

7 days free · No credit card