Refinance a Home Loan: Costs and Break-Even

Refinancing a home loan can reduce your borrowing costs when the saving clearly exceeds the fees of switching. Compare the same balance over the same remaining term, then work out how long the saving takes to recover those fees.

What Refinancing a Home Loan Means

Refinancing means replacing your current mortgage with a new one, at the same lender or a different lender. The new loan pays out the old loan. Simply negotiating a lower rate on your existing contract can avoid replacing the loan altogether.

Moving your home loan to another bank also changes the registered mortgage over the property. At settlement, the old security is discharged and the new lender registers its mortgage.

Why Homeowners Refinance

Homeowners refinance to reduce their rate, consolidate other debts, switch between fixed and variable rates, access equity or add features such as an offset account. A useful feature still has a cost if it comes with higher fees or a higher rate.

For a rate-driven switch, the total saving must clearly exceed the total switching cost over the period you expect to keep the loan. A small monthly reduction is less useful if you plan to sell before recovering the fees.

A fixed-rate period ending, a rate change or a change in your plans is a good reason to review the loan.

If you need a larger loan, such as for renovations, compare cash-out refinancing to release equity with a home loan top-up through your current lender. Each needs a fresh assessment of what you can afford. Adding other debts requires a separate comparison of their repayment periods.

Refinancing a home equity loan follows the same replacement process. Include every loan being paid out in the total balance, then distinguish replacing existing debt from borrowing extra against the property.

There is no general limit on how often you can refinance. Each lender sets its eligibility rules, including any minimum holding period on the existing loan. Repeated switching makes financial sense only when the next saving exceeds another set of costs.

How much you can refinance depends on repayment capacity and the lender’s property valuation. Keeping the new loan at or below 80% of that valuation generally avoids lenders mortgage insurance (LMI). That usually requires at least 20% equity, although exemptions can apply.

The benefits include lower borrowing costs and features that suit your needs. The disadvantages include switching fees, another credit assessment and higher total interest if you extend the term. Refinancing is a good idea when the benefits justify those costs.

If your property value has fallen, your borrowing percentage rises even when the debt has stayed unchanged. A lower valuation can limit the amount available or trigger LMI. Recalculate using the new lender’s valuation before relying on an advertised rate.

Yes, you can refinance an interest-only loan if you meet the new lender’s assessment. A fresh interest-only period needs approval. Compare the principal-and-interest repayments due afterwards so the switch does not hide a later repayment increase.

Retirees can refinance if the lender accepts their income and repayment plan. Retirement changes which income supports the loan and how long repayments remain affordable. GMCU’s retirement repayment guidance shows why a lender can require an evidenced exit strategy when a loan extends into retirement.

Renegotiate Before You Switch

Present a competing written offer to your current lender and ask its retention team for a lower rate or a fee waiver. Moneysmart recommends asking your lender for a better deal before switching.

Yes, you can change your home loan with the same bank. A rate or product change on the existing loan is usually home loan repricing. Replacing the contract with a new loan can still require assessment and fees.

A refinance cashback offer is a one-off payment for taking an eligible new loan. Compare the rate and all fees over your expected holding period, then subtract only cashback you qualify to receive. Check the offer’s eligibility and any repayment conditions. Ask your accountant how its tax treatment applies to your circumstances.

Ask for the revised rate, ongoing fees and any conditions in writing. Compare that retention offer with the external loan over the same remaining term. A slightly higher retained rate can still cost less if it avoids substantial switching fees.

For brokers arranging recurring reviews, refinance timing for existing clients covers when to revisit the loan. A review can end with a negotiated rate on the existing loan.

The Refinancing Process Step by Step

Start by comparing your current loan with a suitable replacement, then apply and arrange settlement if the saving justifies switching.

  1. Audit the current loan. Record its balance, rate, repayment type, remaining term and ongoing fees. Include offset funds and any fixed-rate period still running.
  2. Price the exit costs. Obtain a payout estimate and a written discharge fee. For a fixed loan, request a break-cost quote for the proposed payout timing.
  3. Compare alternatives on total cost. Use the same balance and remaining term, including fees and features you will use. Test the current lender’s retention offer alongside other lenders.
  4. Apply with complete documents. Provide identification, income evidence, current mortgage statements and details of expenses and other debts. A lender can issue conditional approval while documents or a property valuation remain outstanding. Satisfy those conditions before treating approval as final.
  5. Settle the payout. After final approval, sign the loan documents and discharge authority so the lenders can arrange settlement. The new loan pays out the old balance. Confirm the old loan is closed and the new repayment amount, debit account and first payment timing are correct.

The lender assesses repayment capacity and the property securing the loan. CommBank’s refinance process explains the assessment and settlement stages. If the valuation is lower than expected, recalculate the borrowing percentage and costs before proceeding.

Border Bank’s refinance guide gives a typical application-to-settlement timeframe of two to six weeks. The timing depends on document completeness, valuation and lender processing. This includes assessment before loan documents are signed.

How long refinancing takes depends on the assessment, valuation and discharge process. CommBank describes standard refinance settlement as typically taking several weeks after it receives signed loan documents. Application assessment comes before that stage. Missing documents or an unresolved approval condition can delay settlement.

Documents usually include photo identification, income evidence such as payslips or tax returns, recent mortgage statements and details of other debts. Provide your expenses, assets and any evidence the lender needs for rental or retirement income. NAB’s refinance application guide describes these assessment inputs.

A straightforward refinance can be settled by the lenders and their settlement representatives without you appointing a separate conveyancer. If ownership changes or the title has a legal complication, obtain legal advice and confirm who will handle that work before settlement.

Available redraw does not automatically transfer to the new loan. Extra repayments have already reduced the old balance. If you want access to that amount after switching, include it in the requested borrowing, subject to approval. ANZ Plus explains how redraw affects the refinance amount. Confirm the payout and any surplus payment instructions before the old facility closes.

Refinancing Costs to Price

Add the old lender’s charges to the new lender’s fees and government registration costs. Request itemised quotes so a waived application fee does not hide costs elsewhere.

  • The 2011 exit-fee ban covers new variable home loans entered into from the commencement of the ban. The ASIC RG 220 guidance on early termination fees explains covered contracts and exceptions. Older contracts need separate attention.
  • Fixed-rate break costs can still apply when you repay during the fixed period. Obtain a quote because the amount depends on the contract and payout timing.
  • Application, establishment and valuation fees can apply to the new loan. Include ongoing annual or package fees in the comparison too.
  • Discharge and settlement administration fees can apply when closing the old loan.
  • Government mortgage discharge and registration fees can apply when the security changes.

No Australian state or territory charges mortgage duty on a straightforward refinance of the same property with unchanged ownership. NSW was the last jurisdiction to abolish mortgage duty, in 2016, under the Revenue NSW abolition measures. Registration fees and lender charges still apply. Changing property ownership is a separate transaction that can attract transfer duty.

Worked Example: Does the Refinance Pay?

In this hypothetical example, a $500,000 principal-and-interest loan has 30 years remaining. The rate falls from 5% to 4%, the term stays unchanged and switching costs are $2,000 paid separately.

MeasureCurrent LoanNew Loan
Annual interest rate5%4%
Remaining term30 years30 years
Monthly repayment, rounded$2,684$2,387

The monthly repayment falls by about $297. Over the first year, that is about $3,564 less in repayments before switching costs. After the $2,000 upfront cost, the first-year cash-flow improvement is about $1,564.

Divide switching costs by the monthly repayment reduction to estimate cash-flow break-even. Here, $2,000 divided by about $297 is 6.7 months, so the costs are recovered during the seventh month.

This calculation measures repayment relief. Each repayment contains principal and interest, so it is different from an interest-only saving calculation. The example assumes monthly repayments, unchanged rates and no offset balance, extra repayments or fee difference.

A 0.25 percentage point reduction takes years to recover the same costs in this example. Moving from 5% to 4.75% lowers the monthly repayment to about $2,608. The reduction of about $76 recovers $2,000 in roughly 27 months.

Use your actual remaining term and quoted fees. If you add costs to the new loan, recalculate repayments on that larger balance and include the interest charged on those costs.

To calculate whether refinancing a home loan pays, use Moneysmart’s mortgage switching calculator. Enter the current balance and remaining term, both rates and each lender’s fees. Compare the repayment reduction and switching-cost recovery period, then repeat the calculation with the retention offer.

What Refinancing Changes Beyond the Rate

Yes, refinancing can affect your credit score because the formal application can create a credit enquiry. Repeated applications can affect your score, so compare quotes before lodging multiple applications. The OAIC’s credit-report retention table lists five years for a credit enquiry. That retention period does not specify how much your score changes or for how long.

If new borrowing exceeds 80% of the lender’s property valuation, lenders mortgage insurance (LMI) can apply, subject to the lender’s policy and any exemption. LMI protects the lender. A new premium can outweigh the rate saving, even if it is added to the loan balance.

Resetting a loan to 30 years reduces the required repayment by spreading the debt across more months. It can increase total interest despite a lower rate. Compare the remaining term first, then calculate the extra interest separately if you choose a longer term.

Mistakes That Cost the Most

The most costly mistakes distort the comparison between staying and switching.

  • Extending the term without recalculating total interest makes the lower payment look like a saving. Compare repayment totals over both terms before accepting the extension.
  • Comparing too few lenders leaves you without a useful test of the current offer. Compare suitable products across several lenders using the same loan assumptions.
  • Ignoring fees on either side understates the switching cost. Include the payout charges, new loan fees and any LMI in one calculation.
  • Mixing new private spending into an investment-loan refinance makes the interest harder to claim. Interest is generally deductible according to how the borrowed money is used, so keep the original investment borrowing separate from any new private amount. Compare the full remaining cost, and ask a tax adviser how tracing and deductibility apply before settlement. The approval and discharge steps stay the same.

Refinancing a home loan is a good idea when it meets your borrowing needs and the saving clearly exceeds the switching costs. Before signing, compare the retention offer with the preferred refinance over the same remaining term. Proceed when you expect to keep the loan beyond its break-even point.

Track My Trail

Trail analysis, simplified

Less time checking your trail, more time growing your book.

See how it works

7 days free · No credit card

Track My Trail Team

Read more

We develop software to simplify trail book management for mortgage brokers. Our tools provide fast and practical insights to help brokers get the most out of their trail books.

Track My Trail
See how it works

7 days free · No credit card